Incorporating Respiratory Muscle Strengthening into a Physical Therapy Program for an Adult with Pneumonia and Respiratory Failure: A Case Report
Community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) is responsible for 1.1 million hospitalizations in the United States with an averagelength of stay for acute hospitalization for being 5.2 days . CAP causes approximately 50,000 deaths per year in the adultpopulation alone . Acute respiratory failure (ARF) is a complication which can arise if CAP is not treated effectively or in atimely fashion. ARF is estimated to affect 430 per 100,000 patients each year . Complications such as ARF are most commonly observed in patients who have other serious medical conditions such as diabetes or compromised immune systems. Guidelines for the management of CAP for patients with ARF include admission to the ICU, supplemental oxygen therapy,and often ventilator support [3,5]. Patients admitted to the ICU who are treated with non- invasive mechanical ventilation(NIMV) show fewer complications and have better outcomes with shorter stays in the ICU than those who receive invasivemechanical ventilation [3, 6,7]. Mortality for patients admitted to the ICU who receive mechanical ventilation is higher than for patients diagnosed with CAP in earlier stages who may be treated at home or on a regular hospital floor . In addition,patients with a prolonged ICU stay often develop ICU acquired weakness (ICUAW) which has been shown to contribute to functional disability, including profound neuromuscular weakness, and decreased quality of life for survivors [8-10]. PT aimed at early mobilization in the ICU has been shown to decrease the risk of ICUAW, improve outcomes, and decrease costs associated with care in the ICU [8-10]. However, there are limited studies looking at the effects of continued Physical Therapy post-ICU stay and even fewer that look at continued respiratory muscle weakness or training in those patients and the effect it has on their outcome [11-13]. Those studies do not, however, address the scenario described here. The following case chronicles sub-acute PT management of an individual after ICU admission for CAP with ARF. Ongoing reassessment of effectiveness of a PT program aimed primarily at functional training led to the addition of respiratory muscle specific exercisesto enhance endurance and functional outcome.Case Description
Mr. X is a 56 year-old male who presented to the Emergency Room at a community hospital in June of 2014 with the chiefcomplaint of shortness of breath and generalized weakness. He was found to be hypotensive, hypoxic, and had a large right-sided pulmonary infiltrate by imaging. After an extensive workup in the ICU, it was determined that the infiltrate was due to CAP and because of his oxygen requirements (SpO2 on 2L supplemental oxygen via nasal mask was 70%), he was diagnosed with acute hypoxic respiratory failure. He was admitted to the ICU and placed on Vapotherm – a non-invasive high-flow mechanical respiratory support system delivered by nasal cannula used to treat ARF that has been shown to improve oxygenation in hypoxic patients . Mr. X had history of lung cancer and underwent right upper lobectomy in 2009.There was concern initially that the infiltrate noted on imaging could be the return of lung cancer but this was ruled out by the medical team. After 8 days in the ICU, Mr. X was transferred to a medical floor on high-flow oxygen at 15L and was subsequently transferred to a skilled nursing facility (SNF) for shortterm rehabilitation 11 days after admission to the hospital. He received no physical therapy in the acute care hospital and was only assisted from the bed to the chair for short periods of time once out of the ICU. Upon admission to the SNF Mr. X was evaluated by Physical Therapy. Per both the participant and his wife, he had “a lot of medical problems.” In speaking with them about their concerns, they reported he is in remission from lung cancer after having surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation in 2009. They also report that he had poor balance prior to this hospitalization and, due to a history of falls, primarily used a manual wheelchair pushed by his wife when out of his house. He would use a rolling walker (RW) when ambulating short distances in his home – a small single level house with no steps inside or out. The participant states he was often tired and weak and his wife reports he “napped frequently.” His wife was his primary caretaker and helped him with transfers, ambulation, and ADL’s. He had a daughter in high school but did not feel comfortable asking her for help. There were no other supports. He tells the PT that he quit smoking just prior to this illness and that he had used alcohol and heroin in the past but has not used either for “some time.” He is a war veteran and was diagnosed with PTSD, which he feels is responsible for his many medical problems. They report he had no history of using supplemental oxygen at home, not even after his lobectomy in 2009. A medical chart review and review of systems was also completed by PT and findings are as noted in Table 1. Medications Mr. X was receiving upon admission are noted in Table 2.
Mr. X has a complicated medical history. His prior level of function indicates that there may be other processes going on that are yet undiagnosed such as COPD or a neurological disorder that is affecting his overall muscle strength and respiratory muscle strength. As well, his PTSD seems to have been limiting his function prior to this illness as his wife reports he needed encouragement to perform ADL tasks. He had a prolonged ICU stay without early mobilization and is in a severely weakened state. He will need extensive strengthening and endurance training. Although he has some anxiety about Physical Therapy, he is motivated to participate and to ultimately return home.
He was unable to remain standing without maximal assistance from the PT and support of the RW and was only able to maintain this position for 45 seconds before becoming dyspneic and needing to sit, requiring maximal assistance and verbalcueing to use his UE’s. Stand pivot transfers from the bed to his wheelchair and standing from the wheelchair required maximal assistance. Once standing, he was only able to walk 1.5 meters (5 feet) with the RW and maximal assistance from thePT. Gait was noted to be ataxic and he ambulated with a wide base of support, taking small steps due to decreased stancephase bilaterally. He had moderate dyspnea after walking the 1.5 meters. He required frequent rest periods during the examination and instruction and demonstration by the PT for diaphragmatic and pursed lip breathing throughout the examination. His SpO2 remained at 90% on 13L oxygen. Mr. X was unable to tolerate a 6MWT or any other formal functional assessment testing.
Mr. X required maximal assistance to perform all transfers and was unable to ambulate without maximal assistance or greaterthan 1.5 meters. He demonstrated severe dyspnea on exertion (DOE) and use of accessory muscles during breathing – in particular sternocleidomastoid, pectoralis muscles, and trapezius – with poor use of his diaphragm and intercostals. He had difficulty performing diaphragmatic and pursed lip breathing even with verbal and visual instruction.
Week One: PT initially focused on general muscle strengthening starting with supine and seated therapeutic exercises for both upper and lower extremities and trunk in straight planes (sagittal and coronal), initially without weights then progressingslowly to use of weights, starting with a 1/2 pound and gradually increasing weight to tolerance. Transfer training alsoprogressed smoothly working on sit to stand activities from both a raised exercise mat and chair focusing on eccentric andconcentric contraction of the quadriceps and hamstring muscles. Trunk strengthening exercises were combined with balanceactivities and initially performed seated progressing to standing. Activities included reaching out of base of support in both sagittal and coronal planes as well as trunk rotation. Mr. X often had difficulty with diaphragmatic and pursed lip recoverybreathing requiring verbal, visual, and tactile cues during exercise and when resting. SpO2 was monitored during exercise and remained in the low 90’s on 13 L. At the end of week one, he was able to maintain static standing balance with the use of his RW with contact guard from the PT for two minutes and partially complete a 6MWT (see Table 4). He was unable to carry on a conversation at the end of the test. It took over five minutes his SpO2 to return to 93% and for the dyspnea to subside to an MBS rating of 1 (very slight). He was severely fatigued and discouraged.Week Two: Of concern to PT was that although Mr. X was progressing with general strength and static balance, he was notprogressing with endurance to ambulation and other functional activities such as ADL’s with OT. He continued to becomeseverely dyspneic during these activities with SpO2 frequently dropping to low 80’s on 13 L of supplemental oxygen requiringlong rest periods. Although not the primary focus of Mr. X’s treatment plan, diaphragmatic and pursed lip breathing exercises were being performed more as a way to recover from dyspnea than to strengthen respiratory musculature. It was decided to look at adding respiratory strengthening exercises to his PT plan of care. A review of the literature was done to see if there was some way to assist Mr. X with his continued breathing difficulties and low endurance. A case study by Chang A et al showed that inspiratory muscle training in addition to a standard physical therapy protocol can be beneficial for patients who have had an ICU stay with prolonged mechanical ventilation . A study by Tout R et al in which patients with COPD who had diaphragmatic muscle training in conjunction with a standard PT protocol showed that respiratory muscle training is beneficial . Another study looking at the use of inspiratory muscle training (IMT) combined with expiratory muscle training (EMT) showed that the use of IMT and IMT plus EMT were both beneficial to increase respiratory muscle strength . Mr. X did not technically have COPD but had a history of lobectomy. No literature was found specifically describing the scenario of CAP with ARF after lobectomy and whether or not respiratory muscle training would help. It was decided that respiratory muscle training may be beneficial and was added to his treatment plan since there was literature proving that it was beneficial in patients who had had a prolonged ICU stay and in patients with other similar respiratory diagnoses who experienced persistent DOE.
Mr. X was started with simple diaphragmatic breathing exercises in supine with the goals of reducing dyspnea, normalizing his breathing pattern, and decreasing the work of breathing . Diaphragmatic breathing exercises were started in supine with the head of the bed elevated approximately 45 degrees. Using both verbal instruction and demonstration by the PT, he was instructed to place one hand over his diaphragm approximately 1 inch above the umbilicus and the other hand on the center of his chest. He was then instructed to breathe normally and try to feel the pattern of his breathing – when each hand would rise and lower. Once he was able to feel the pattern he was asked to “elevate” the hand over his diaphragm when he inhaled and to “lower” when he exhaled while at the same time trying to keep the hand over his chest from moving excessively. Mr. X had a great deal of difficulty with this and it took 3 separate sessions of PT for him to begin to do it correctly. Once he was able to perform this exercise in supine it was started in sitting and progressed to unsupported sitting and then standing and finally being able to use the diaphragmatic breathing pattern during ambulation and ADL’s over the course of two weeks.
Segmental breathing exercises were also initiated, focusing on the lower lobes with the goal to augment lung expansion andultimately improve strength, endurance and efficiency of the respiratory system . To perform these exercises, the participant was first given a demonstration by the PT using another PT as a “patient.” The therapist placed her hands over the lower lateral costal areas bilaterally. The participant was instructed to take a deep breath, breathing into the therapist’s hands. Once maximal inspiration was reached, the participant was instructed to hold his breath for two seconds then forcefully exhale. The exhalation was assisted by gentle force from the PT’s hands. The individual was then told to inspire and resistance was applied to the lower lateral costal area by the PT. The resistance was gradually lessened toward the end of full inspiration. This was repeated 3-5 times as tolerated then he was allowed to rest before repeating for a total of 3 cycles every PT session. Over a week, this exercise became progressively easier for Mr. X and he was able to complete 5 repetitions for each cycle. Mr. X was also given an inspiratory muscle resistive training device to use on his own after initial training by the PT. He used this two times a day for 15 minutes for the last two weeks of PT with the goal of increasing strength and endurance of respiratory muscles .
At the end of the third week, marked improvement was noted in the participant’s endurance evidenced by less dyspnea during functional tasks and increased distance with ambulation. At the end of his PT (a total of three weeks with the last 2 having incorporated breathing exercises) Mr. X was able to complete a 6MWT using a RW without oxygen. He was discharged home three weeks after his admission to SNF walking independently with a RW. He was also able to walk up and down 6 steps using railings for support – something he had not been able to do prior to this spell of illness.
The addition of respiratory muscle strengthening exercises seemed to enhance Mr. X’s PT program. This was observed asimproved respiratory function not only during functional mobility, but the individual developed a stronger voice and his overall outlook became more positive as he was able to perform tasks without becoming dyspneic. In addition, the 6MWT showed that there was a clinically significant change in Mr. X’s function from initial (7.6m) to final performance of test (656 meters) (MDC = 66.3m) and his MBS rating went from 5 (severe dyspnea) to 2 (slight dyspnea) (MCID = 1 unit) [17,18, 21]. Prior to adding these exercises, progress was noted in musculoskeletal strength but not in endurance – mostly contributed to the dyspnea that he was experiencing. This was discouraging to Mr. X – he did not feel he was making progress.
We know that classical mechanical ventilation can result in diaphragm weakness. NIMV is shown to have fewer complicationsbut there is no research indicating whether or not weakened respiratory muscles may result from its use. Mr. X had not hadinvasive mechanical ventilation, which may have been a more obvious flag to the PT indicating the need for the addition ofrespiratory muscle exercises. It was assumed that since Mr. X had not had invasive mechanical ventilation, there would not be significant respiratory muscle weakness that would interfere with his rehabilitation. However, there were signs initially that may have been red flags indicating respiratory muscle weakness may be present – either due to NIVN, ICUAW, or the absence of early mobilization in the ICU. The individual was on high flow O2 at 13 L, had severe dyspnea on exertion, and difficultyperforming diaphragmatic breathing. He also had a low functional level prior to his admission to the hospital.
Should these have alerted the PT that Mr. X may have respiratory muscle weakness and that the initial focus of his rehabilitation should have been respiratory muscle training? In reviewing literature to answer this question, one study that wasfound was by Berry M and Morris P and entitled Early exercise rehabilitation of muscle weakness in acute respiratory failurepatients. The PT focus in this study was solely on skeletal muscle weakness and strengthening – there is no mention of respiratory muscle strengthening exercises .No literature was found discussing respiratory muscle weakness or the use of respiratory muscle strengthening exercises after NIMV. It would be beneficial to have future clinical studies that look atpatients post ICU stay who have had NIMV to determine if expanding the red flag list for the possibility of respiratory muscleweakness related to NIMV would be warranted and to see if there is a true correlation between the addition of respiratorystrengthening exercises to a PT plan of care versus a more traditional course of sub-acute PT in these patients.
Conflict of Interest
Author declares no conflict of interest or sources of funding.
2.National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases and National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases. Pneumonia can be Prevented. Centers for Disease Control. Published February 18, 2014.
3.Williams JW, Cox CE, Daniel L Gilstrap, Christian E Castillo, Hargett CW, et al. Noninvasive Positive-Pressure Ventilation (NPPV) for Acute Respiratory Failure. Comparative Effectiveness Review Executive Summary No. 68. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Published July 2012.
5.Mandell LA, Wunderink RG, Anzueto A, Bartlett JG, Campbell GD. Infectious Diseases Society of America/American Thoracic Society Consensus Guidelines on the Management of Community- Acquired Pneumonia in Adults. Clinical Infectious Diseases. 2007, 44(2): 527-572.
6.Honrubia T, García López FJ, Franco N, Mas M, Guevara M. Noninvasive vs conventional mechanical ventilation in acute respiratory failure: A multicenter, randomized controlled trial. Chest 2005, 128(6): 3916-3924.
7.Schnell D, Timsit J-F, Darmon M, Aurélien Vesin, Dany Goldgran-Toledano et al. Noninvasive mechanical ventilation in acute respiratory failure: trends in use and outcomes. Intensive Care Med. 2014, 40(4): 582-591.
11.Yosef-Brauner O, Adi N, Ben Shahar T, Ester Yehezkel, Eli Carmeli et al. Effect of physical Therapy on muscle strength , respiratory muscles, and functional parameters in patients with intensive care unit-acquired weakness. Clin Respir J. 2013, 9(1): 1-6.
15.American Physical Therapy Association (APTA). Guide to Physical Therapist Practice, Second Edition. Alexandria, VA: APTA. 2003.
18.Segura-Ortí E, Martínez-Olmos FJ. Test-retest reliability and minimal detectable change scores for sit-to-stand-to-sit tests, the six-minute walk test, the one-leg heel-rise test, and handgrip strength in people undergoing hemodialysis. Phys Ther. 2011, 91(8): 1244-1252.
23.Tout R, Tayara L, Halimi M. The effects of respiratory muscle training on improvement of the internal and external thoraco- pulmonary respiratory mechanism in COPD patients. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2013, 56(3): 193-211.
24.Neves LF, Reis MH, Plentz RD, Matte DL, Coronel CC et al. Expiratory and Expiratory Plus Inspiratory Muscle Training Improves Respiratory Muscle Strength in Subjects With COPD: Systematic Review. Respir Care. 2014, 59(9): 1381-1388.