Neurosyphilis – Still a Diagnostic and Therapeutic Challenge
Corresponding author: Dr. Lars Gustafson, Section of Geriatric Psychiatry, Department of Clinical Sciences Lund, Lund Uni- versity, Klinikgatan 22, SE-221 85 Lund Sweden. Tel: +46 46177450; Email: email@example.com
The first description of paralysie générale (general paralysis of the insane) was published in 1822 . However, the infec- tious aetiology of the disease was not described until 1913  and a potential cure, fever therapy was introduced by Wag- ner-Jauregg in 1917 . Consequently neurosyphilis became an important “paradigm-disease,” and a model for other men- tal diseases. It became possible for the disease to be diagnosed with reasonable certainty, albeit easily misinterpreted and misdiagnosed. Neurosyphilis has been described as “the great
imitator” presenting with a wide spectrum of clinical manifes- tations .
Traditionally syphilis is divided into primary, secondary, la- tent and tertiary stages. The primary stage classically presents with local skin ulceration at the site of inoculation, secondary syphilis with generalized skin lesions (a rush frequently seen on palms of hands and/or soles of the feet), latent stage with little or no symptoms (can last up to 30 years) and the tertia- ry stage with lesions such as gummas, neurological or cardiac symptoms. Neurosyphilis is often referred as tertiary syphilis,but can occur at any time in the course of syphilis [5, 6].
Neurosyphilis, along with the cardiovascular form of syphilis, is known as tertiary syphilis. In the central nervous system (CNS), it may involve the meninges, the brain and spinal cord parenchyma and the ependymal zone, appearing in the form of either meningovascular or parenchymatous neurosyphilis (or both). There is always a component of vascular engagement, the most prominent form referred to as Heubner arteritis . The variety of structural changes that appear within the CNS underlies the spectrum of clinical manifestations that may make diagnosis of neurosyphilis difficult to reach. The vascular affection is specifically pertinent in this report.
Recognized as a sexually transmitted disease, syphilis ap- peared in Sweden in the late 15th century and ravaged the country in the following centuries, . Seventy years ago a comparatively large proportion of beds at the mental hospital in Lund were occupied by patients with syphilis, and about 10
% of all deaths at the hospital were caused by the disease from 1930 to 1949. A malignant course was predominant, often re- sulting in death within three months to two years after admis- sion. The diagnosis has become relatively unusual in Sweden and tertiary manifestations are rare. In 2010 the Swedish In- stitute of Infectious Disease Control (SBL) reported 199 new cases of syphilis, in 75 % of these the detection was based on both clinical and laboratory diagnostics. Primary syphilis was found in 62 cases (31 %), secondary in 27 cases (14 %) and in 46 cases (33 %) an early or late latent phase of syphilis was found. The remaining 64 cases (32 %) were diagnosed as an unspecified stage of the disease. The incidence of syphilis in Sweden was 2, 0 /100 000 in 2011, with a marked increase since 2000. In 2013, 275 new cases were reported, an increase of 37 % compared with the year 2012 .
Our aim of this paper was to report two middle-aged male pa- tients suffering from tertiary syphilis who were referred to the Psychiatric and the Psychogeriatric departments in Lund, Swe- den, for diagnosis and treatment of an unexplained mental dis- order with organic traits. The patients were treated success- fully with penicillin and regained full working capacity. They were followed-up clinically for 33 and 21 years respectively. The diagnosis was based on clinical symptoms and support- ed by positive cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), serological data and brain imaging. In one of the cases the diagnosis was also con- firmed by neuropathological examination. The patients were examined according to the routine clinical care.
A 38-year old man, with no prior diagnosis or treatment of mental illness sought help from his local general practitioner (GP). There was no heredity for dementia or other neuropsy- chiatric disease. He had slight dyslexia and had suffered a single epileptic seizure of unknown cause at the age of 6. At
the age of 23 he suffered a brain concussion related to a traf- fic accident. In all other aspects he had been a healthy person, working full-time with no sick leave for the last 15 years. Pre- viously a rather shy and quiet person, at the age of 38 his be- haviour slowly changed and he started to talk loudly to himself when he was alone. He was aware of his strange behaviour but unable to control the voluble flow of words and associations. When the condition worsened he contacted his GP, who re- ferred him to the general hospital. The preliminary diagnosis at the acute medical ward was mania with psychotic symptoms and the patient was referred to the Psychiatric department. At admittance he seemed exhausted; he talked incessantly both day and night, was sometimes incoherent and pleaded for help to calm down and to “shut off his over-talking”. He was lucid and fully oriented but restless with a slight increase of mood tone. No major neurological abnormalities were observed but there was a slight dysarthria with a nasal twang. His mimic movements were sparse, with episodic paramimic twitch- ings (uncontrolled muscle movements in the face). His hand movements were fumbling and his handwriting unsteady. The preliminary diagnosis was “manic-like organic mental syn- drome” and the diagnostic process leant towards an infectious cause (rabies was suggested), a metabolic disease, an inflam- matory or a tumorous process. Electroencephalogram (EEG) showed a general non-focalized slowing without focal abnor- malities. The body temperature fluctuated between 37 and 38 centigrades. A computerized tomography (CT) could not be completed because of severe agitation. CSF analysis showed monocytic pleocytosis and a slightly increased protein level. The IgG-index was 1, 00 with multiple bands in the gamma re- gion. There were no indications of metabolic or toxic factors involved. On the fifth day a positive Wasserman reaction (WR) was noted, later confirmed with a positive fluorescent trepo- nemal antibody absorption test (FTA-ABS) in blood. Repeated CSF analyses supported the diagnosis of tertiary neurosyphilis and additional clinical information indicated that the primary infection had occurred 8-10 years earlier.
He was treated with procaine benzylpenicillin for three weeks (intramuscular, 600.000 IE daily) after premedication with prednisolone. This resulted in an exacerbation of the clinical somatic symptoms, interpreted as a severe Jarish-Herxheimer reaction . The patient showed ataxia, astasia, left-sid- ed ptosis, urinary retention, fever and headache for several weeks. The patient slowly improved and was discharged af- ter five months of hospital care. At a follow-up one year later he reported good physical and mental health, and was almost back to his premorbid condition. He was fully oriented with a fairly normal speed of speech and demonstrated full working capacity. The positive report was confirmed by the patient’s close relatives. The patient was followed up with CSF analysis and measurements of regional cerebral blood flow (CBF with two-dimensional 133-Xenon-inhalation technique) on several occasions .The results showed a global blood flow level within the lower part of the normal zone with slight regional reductions frontally. A Single Photon Emission Computerized Tomography (SPECT) eleven years after the antibiotic therapy showed moderate focal reductions within right frontal and left temporal cortical areas (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Tomographic rCBF measurement (Ceretec-SPECT) eleven years after diagnosis, showed moderate focal reductions within left temporal (left arrow) and right frontal cortical (right arrow) areas.
The patient worked full-time in his profession, which was the same as prior to the disease, and he retired at the age of 63 years. At this age he was still living at home with normal dai- ly abilities and social contacts. Three years later a slowly pro- gressive mental deterioration was observed and he moved to a home for the aged. At the age of 69 he was fully oriented, but with a slight memory failure for recent events. He showed a slight dysarthria, logorrhea and hyperorality. Hypomimia and echolalia, components of the PEMA syndrome (palilalia, echo- lalia, mutism and amimia) were also noted. Both the PEMA syndrome and hyperorality can be seen in patients with Fron- totemporal dementia (FTD) [12,13]. His gait gradually became slow and staggering, with need for support. The emotional contact with his nearest remained relatively well preserved. He died at the age of 71 years, 33 years after the established diagnosis of neurosyphilis and subsequent treatment.
The immediate cause of death was a massive aspiration. The autopsy with detailed neuropathological examination showed bilateral atrophy of the frontal poles and atrophy of the frontal and temporal lobes. Due to the finding of gliosis and reduction of nerve cells in many cortical areas, along with a lack of de- tectable specific protein pathology, the morphological alter- ations were judged to be associated with the known previous syphilis, and thus of post-infectious type . The parietal and occipital lobes were preserved as were the substantia nigra and locus coeruleus. The neuropathological investigation also showed a particular advanced atheromatosis and arterioscle- rosis of the basal vessels most marked in the posterior circula- tion i.e. the vertebral and basilar vessels. Even more prominent was a stenosing arteriosclerosis of intracerebral vessels of ex- traordinary type, judged to be the late effects of an endarteritis of the primary infectious disease. Bilateral lacunar infarctions were found within the striatum, topographically related to the site where the most severely stenosed parenchymal vessels were found (Figure 2).
Figure 2. Microphotograph of a small meningeal artery exhibiting the same characteristic traits as does numerous vessels within the brain of case 1. As a result of a previous endarteritis, the intima and me- dia is thickened by a proliferation of fibroblasts, collagen and smooth muscle cells (enlarged in inset photo), while there is no current in- flammation. Hematoxylin-eosin staining.
This patient thus presented a rather dramatic organic brain syndrome eight to ten years after the primary infection. The clinical diagnosis was confirmed by traditional analyses of CSF and blood. The treatment with penicillin was successful, with almost full recovery after one year. This normalization was fol- lowed by thirty years of normal mental and physical health un- til a second period of mental deterioration started, three years before death.
Accompanied by a colleague, a 44 year old academic teacher contacted his GP. The patient suffered hepatitis type B fifteen years earlier, but was otherwise in good physical health. There was no heredity for dementia or other neuropsychiatric dis- ease. The premorbid personality was described as normal with a pleasant, warm and empathic attitude towards his fam- ily and other people.
During the four months prior to seeking help his personality and behaviour were gradually changing. He became emotion- ally apathetic and detached. A general psychomotor retarda- tion, increased fatigue, memory failure and irritability were also seen. Alcohol problems and drug addiction were denied. The physical examination was described as normal, although the neurological investigation showed suspected lively tendon reflexes bilaterally. An organic brain disease was suspected and the patient was referred to the Psychogeriatric depart- ment. A laboratory screening was performed including WR. CT scan and MRI showed a slight dilatation of the lateral and third ventricles and EEG showed a general diffuse slowing without focal or epileptogenic changes. A second MRI, two weeks later, showed a widened fissure Sylvii and ventricles and T2 hyper-intensities indicating a previous inflammatory process. An ini- tial CBF-examination (two- dimensional 133-Xenon-inhalation technique) showed a moderately subnormal flow level and slight to moderate flow reductions in multiple regions includ- ing right frontotemporal and parietal regions and the left dor- sal parietal region (Figure 3).
Figure 3. Vertex projections of the cortical blood flow distribution using the 2-D 133-Xenon inhalation technique . The two upper panels show the results from the patient. As a comparison the lower picture shows data from a normal reference group. The mean hemi- spheric cortical blood flow values (ISI 2-3-parameter) are shown in the lower part of each panel. The regional values are shown as color coded percentages of the hemispheric mean.
The initial examination (1994-04-25) showed a slightly subnormal flow level and slight to moderate focal reductions in right frontotem- poral and parietal regions and in left dorsal parietal areas. A follow up examination eight weeks after treatment (1994-07-06) showed an evident normalization of both the general blood flow level (34 % in- crease) and the regional pathology. Only a slight blood flow reduction in a right prefrontal area persists.
The patient was referred to the Neurologic department. He showed a lack of focus and was slightly disoriented as to the date and day of the week. The examination showed lively pal- momental reflexes, lively tendon reflexes, pouting, an undecid- ed Babinski sign but normal muscular tension and sensibility. CSF showed an increased number of mononuclear cells strong- ly indicating an infectious disease. The patient was sometimes agitated, lacking insight and repeatedly left the hospital in a state of confusion. Compulsory care was motivated for a short period and the patient was referred to the psychiatric depart- ment for further examination and treatment. During the follow- ing week his gait was slow and staggering. His answers were terse and he stared with an intense gaze which was sometimes accompanied by an inadequate, disinhibited smile. He partly lacked insight, but admitted that his memory had deteriorated
during the last six months. His memory was fragmented and fluctuating, he showed lack of concentration and was irrita- ble. The tentative aetiology was an infectious or inflammato- ry brain disease. Three weeks after the first referral, syphilis serology presented a positive TPHA-test and WR resulting in treatment with benzylpenicillin. The patient soon reacted with fever and exanthema and prednisolone was added against the expected Herxheimer reaction . The patient gradual- ly improved but showed signs of marked depression. Ten days after the treatment was initiated, an exanthema appeared on the chest and the penicillin was replaced with broad spectrum antibiotics. The patient readily agreed to stay in hospital. He often lay on his bed, smoking carelessly and stubbing his ciga- rettes out on the bedside table. This regressive behaviour was less pronounced when he visited his family at home. Eventual- ly his behaviour and memory improved, as did the serological parameters. After eight weeks of penicillin treatment a follow up CBF examination, showed a clear normalization with less pronounced focal pathology and a normal general blood flow level (Figure 3).
The patient was discharged three and a half months after his first referral. His wife antedated the clinical onset of the dis- ease to about ten months earlier, reporting tiredness, emotion- al changes and memory failure as being the initial symptoms. At discharge the patient showed a normal emotional contact. He was lucid, fully oriented with insight and self-critical com- ments on his previous behaviour and was able to resume his previous profession.
He was followed-up every second year for ten years with blood and CSF examinations. MR three years after admission, showed ventricles with normal width, and no other brain pathology.
At a follow up after ten years the patient, still working full time in his previous profession, described himself as somewhat tired but otherwise fully recovered. At the age of 62 the patient retired, but was still in good health. At a recent follow-up, 21 years after the first referral, the pa- tient remained in good physical and mental health.
These two case reports illustrate the importance of considering the diagnosis of neurosyphilis in patients with mental illness, especially when presenting a clinical picture with atypical and unexpected organic features. Several alternative diagnoses were suggested before neurosyphilis was considered. In the first diagnostic round mania, bipolar affective disorder, delir- ium, schizophrenia-like psychosis, cerebrovascular disease, FTD and even rabies were suggested. In our experience, pa- tients with neurosyphilis may present a large variety of clini- cal features, including psychiatric symptoms and neurological signs and may therefore remain undiagnosed, thus delaying the treatment that has been available since the introduction ofpyrexia therapy in 1917 and penicillin and other antibiotics in the mid forties’ .
The outcome depends on early diagnosis and efficient treat- ment. The clinical follow-up has to consider aggravation with the possibility of a severe Herxheimer reaction in spite of the protective umbrella based on the combination of antibiotics and corticosteroids.
Neurosyphilis remains a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge. The aim of this paper was to elucidate the clinical outcome of neurosyphilis in a long time perspective. A particular feature, demonstrated in case 1, is that of severe and widespread vas- cular sclerotic pathology, judged to be a sequel of the syphilitic endarteritis .
It is important that each new generation of psychiatrists takes on the challenge of diagnosis and treatment of paral- ysie générale, although there are a limited number of recent publications on these clinical issues. Our conclusion is that the recognition of neuropsychiatric features and the use of rou- tine screening tests for syphilis are necessary in this process. The good news is that even patients with a dramatic cognitive deterioration and deranged behaviour may well respond to traditional antibiotic treatment with a remarkable and lasting physical and mental recovery.
This study was supported by the Trolle-Wachtmeister Founda- tion. Helena Andersson is thanked for the preparation of the manuscript.
- Bayle ALJ. Recherches sur les Maladies Mentales. Paris: Thése de Médecine, 1822.
- Noguchi H, Moore JW. A Demonstration of Treponema Pal- lidum in the Brain in Cases of General Paralysis. J Exp Med. 1913, 17: 232-238.
- Karamanou M, Liappas I, Antoniou C, Androutsos G, Lyko- uras E. Julius Wagner-Jauregg (1857-1940): Introducing fever therapy in the treatment of neurosyphilis. Psychiatriki. 2013, 24: 208-212.
- Berrios GE. Delirium and cognate states. Clinical section. In: Berrios GE, Porter R, editors. A History of Clinical Psychiatry. The Origin and History of Psychiatric Disorders. London: The Athlone Press, 1995, 3-22.
- Hook EW, 3rd, Marra CM. Acquired syphilis in adults. N Engl J Med. 1992, 326: 1060-1069.
- Marra CM. Update on neurosyphilis. Curr Infect Dis Rep. 2009, 11: 127-134.
- Al-Shammari NE, El-Beltagi AH, Al-Far SA, Abdel-Raouf YM. Syphilitic arteritis involving the origin of the cervical internal carotid artery. Neurosciences (Riyadh). 2010, 15: 122-125.
- Cronberg S. The rise and fall of sexually transmitted diseases in Sweden. Genitourin Med. 1993, 69: 184-186.
- Smittskyddsinstitutet. Statistik för syphilis, 2014.
- Silberstein P, Lawrence R, Pryor D, Shnier R. A case of neu- rosyphilis with a florid Jarisch-Herxheimer reaction. J Clin Neurosci. 2002;9: 689-690.
- Risberg J. Regional cerebral blood flow measurements by 133Xe-inhalation: methodology and applications in neuropsy- chology and psychiatry. Brain Lang. 1980, 9: 9-34.
- Brun A, Englund E, Gustafson L. Consensus statement – Clinical and neuropathological criteria for frontotemporal de- mentia. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1994, 57: 416-418.
- Landqvist Waldo M, Gustafson L, Nilsson K. Frontotempo- ral dementia with a C9ORF72 expansion in a Swedish family: clinical and neuropathological characteristics. Am J Neurode- gener Dis. 2013, 2: 276-286.
- Oates JK. Serological tests for syphilis and their clinical use. Br J Hosp Med. 1979;21: 612-617.
- Hahn RD, Webster B, Weickhardt G. Penicillin treatment of general paresis (dementia paralytica). AMA Arch Neurol Psy- chiatry. 1959, 81: 557-590.
- Khamaysi Z, Bergman R, Telman G, Goldsher D. Clinical and imaging findings in patients with neurosyphilis: a study of a cohort and review of the literature. Int J Dermatol. 2014, 53: 812-819.